357 vs 10mm bear.

Railsplitter said: I contacted Underwood and you are correct they recommend their 140gr XP first and their 200 and 220gr cast bullet loads second for confronting brown bears. Here is their answer to my inquiry on this subject. Underwood Technicians <[email protected]>.I know what you're saying about load vs load, but I got a 10mm because it was close to or equal to .357 mag but could carry more than 6. I dont think capacity should be discounted. When hiking I carry the buff bore 10mm. It's over, barely, 700 fpe. The 357 buff bore is closer to 800, and that's because the 357 is using a lighter bullet going ...Get a hollow point round. Black bears are not overly tough like their bigger and meaner cousins. People who say otherwise have not personally had to deal with them. Although, if you have a 10mm pistol or a revolver larger than the .357 available to you, just take that instead of buying something new. 5.The difference between 10mm vs 357 Magnum is that the 10mm was designed for use in semi-auto handguns while the 357 Mag was designed for use in revolvers. The 357 Mag …The .45 ACP is great for self-defense; it's a hard-hitting caliber that will easily protect you from two-legged varmints. Unfortunately, bears have a much thicker hide, bones, fur, and body mass than the .45 ACP can comfortably handle. It just doesn't have adequate stopping power or deep penetration needed for taking down big game animals.

Just no. Shooting a bear with a .40 or a 10mm or a .223 is my option near the bottom of the list. Running is a better one. Tin Foil Free Zone. Eagle Scout. ... which seems to be the generally accepted minimum by those who've never shot a black bear. A .357 mag is oft-times considered "ok" for such things, and a well loaded .40 S&W is …Here's the rounds, from Buffalo Bore: .45 ACP +P Ammo - 255 gr. Hard Cast FN (925 fps/M.E. 484 ft. lbs.) Heavy 10mm Ammo - 220 gr. Hard Cast - FN (1,200 fps/ME 703 ft. lbs.) My pistol choices are the Glock 29 or 30 for these rounds since I already shoot well with Glocks and don't want to learn a new platform. I will also be using whichever gun ...10mm VS .357 Magnum Winchester Silvertip Gel Test. I know the 10mm semiauto pistol has become somewhat popular for predator protection (e.g., bears), but I also have to remark that I see absolutely no advantage over the 450 SMC in 45ACP, which instead of 170 grains at 1235 FPS is 230 grains at 1120 FPS, with only a change to the spring in a 1911.

Depending on which website you go to there seems to be conflicting opinion regarding ballistics. Thinking in terms of trail protection, is it fair to say they are pretty damned close, if you want a semi-auto go with a 10mm, if you want a revolver take the .357, but basically other than ...Also, max budget is 1k. The guns I’m looking at right now are. 10mm Glock 20 Glock 40 Sig p220 Some 1911 in 10mm-Ruger, Smith and Wesson, Springfield ronin, colt delta elite if I can find one for a decent price. 357 Ruger gp100 Smith 586/686. 45 super HK 45 (would do USP but my smedium hands prob wouldn’t work great with its chonky grip)

Jul 20, 2020 · Testing out which cartridge is better between 10mm Auto and .357 Magnum. To do that, I am using guns that have equal amount of bullet travel in the guns and ... Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...Not the worse choice if staying with a pistol with a full length barrel (4 inches or more). The .40 is a high pressure cartridge-basically all loads in it are +p, you do not see +p .40 ammo for this reason. Penetration with 180 grain loads surpasses 9mm and .45 auto loads. The .40 has more energy in most loads also.The glock 20 holds 15 rounds flush mags and gen 5 comes milled from the factory for an optic. If im walking in the woods and get a bear charging on my I don't need a scoped 357 or a 6 shot revolver. I'd take a 15-20 round glock 20 10mm with proper ammo any day over a revolver.

Self-Defense vs. Hunting. It's worth noting that the test standards outlined above were developed with human targets in mind. For animals, the 150% expansion and the 12-18" penetration guidelines do not necessarily apply. 10mm has recently gained some popularity as a hunting cartridge for small to medium game, and it also comes up often in discussions about "wilderness defense" against ...

9mm and 10mm had almost identical results when passing through gel- 69 inches of gel for both. 9mm and 10mm had very similar results when passing through the synthetic bear head- both had straight line penetration, and both had some shots that deflected in some fashion. Both guys agree 9mm punched above expectations.

Alaska Airlines unveils its care coalition campaign with help from a Care Bear to celebrate its subscription pass for West Coast travel. We’re not sure if they picked, or “picked u...The .357 magnum revolver with hardcast bullets has even more "oomph" than 10mm. For a similar sized gun, a .44 mag has even more. For the 9 vs 10 argument, penetration, so projectile type is key. A 10mm 135gr Gold Dot isn't going to be as effective as a 9mm 147g hardcast. Why do these threads pop up weekly? The 357 Magnum has more potential energy than a 10mm AUTO. According to S.A.A.M.I, the 357 Magnum has more case capacity and higher max pressure. The 357 has a wider selection of bullets and fires at a greater velocity than the 10mm with the same weight bullets and penetrates marginally better. Both the .357 and 10mm have unique strengths and ... A .357 hardcast 180grain moving between 1200 and 1400 fps. will penetrate the biggest bear up close and destroy the vital organs. The 500 S&W up close will do the same thing, with a slightly bigger hole, a .38 and a .50, not a big difference. ... .45 Colt +P vs 10mm: Ok, the .45 Colt +P round, ... So nowdays, if I am in the area of bears, I ...A .357 hardcast 180grain moving between 1200 and 1400 fps. will penetrate the biggest bear up close and destroy the vital organs. The 500 S&W up close will do the same thing, with a slightly bigger hole, a .38 and a .50, not a big difference. ... .45 Colt +P vs 10mm: Ok, the .45 Colt +P round, ... So nowdays, if I am in the area of bears, I ...The 10mm auto cartridge with a height of 0.992" has an average speed of 1199 fps from a 6" barrel and has an average 546 foot pounds per square inch of energy, while the 40 Smith & Wesson has a height of 0.85" travels around 1074 fps from a 6" barrel and has an average 423 foots pounds per square inch. The numbers don't lie and neither does the ...

Feb 16, 2024 · The .357 Magnum, having greater case capacity, has the potential to be more powerful, but the 10mm also tends to use heavier bullets. It’s also worth noting that recoil is affected by the type of firearm in use. Revolvers tend to recoil more, all else being equal, and the .357 Magnum is mostly a revolver cartridge. 10mm vs. .357 Magnum for bear protection? in Episode 3 we have Underwood Xtreme Penetrators and more redneck science. What do you use for bear protection? S...10mm 200 gr XTP, 7.1 grains CFE Pistol at 1060 fps. 44 mag 300 gr XTP, 17.5 grains H110 at 1093 fps. The 10mm is a true .400" caliber whereas the 44 actually measures .429" diameter. Interestingly enough, there was little velocity difference between the loads even with just over 10 more grains of powder in the 44 mag.Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Feb 19, 2018 · Alaska Geologist Pistol Defense failure June 20, 2010, Grizzly Bear, .357 Magnum. ... I’d prefer and XD 10mm for large bear country, too. 15 rounds of FMJ is a wise defense here, also. I live in ...

vis35. 379 posts · Joined 2010. #18 · Jul 7, 2010 (Edited) Gee guys, Black Bear are not that hard to kill. Seriously, any good personal defense handgun caliber will kill a Black Bear, .357 Sig, .40 S&W, 10MM, .45 ACP, even 9MM. I am not talking about hunting; I am talking about killing a Black Bear at 10 to 20 feet.

The 357 Mag and 10mm have found their homes in the woods, but admittedly in different areas. The 10mm cartridge and Glock 20 are the most popular semi-auto offerings sold in Alaska. The 10mm is a potent bear deterrent with its deep penetration and high muzzle velocity.10mm Auto or 44 Magnum for Bear defense, that is the question! Revolver or high capacity automatic? I note actual Bear charges that people have used pistols...The 357mag is capable of the same energy, if not more, than the 10mm. You 10mm worshippers are ridiculous. I never compared the 10mm to the .357. The statement was inferior to the 9mm, .40, & .45. I actually quoted it. If you knew how to read the quote on my post, maybe you would have seen that.Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...Since the 44 Magnum always beats out the 357 Magnum in terms of stopping power, it comes as no surprise that it trounces the newer 10mm as well. ... the 44 Mag's definitive stopping power will prove more effective for boar, deer, and even bear. A semi-auto 10mm handgun naturally offers increased shot capacity, a faster rate of fire, and an ...The minimum recommended caliber for grizzly bear defense is typically .357 Magnum, with larger calibers being preferred for maximum effectiveness. 12. Is a 10mm more powerful than a .357 Magnum? In general, a 10mm is more powerful than a .357 Magnum, making it a popular choice for bear defense. 13. Can a .38 Special be used for brown bear defense?

Depending on which website you go to there seems to be conflicting opinion regarding ballistics. Thinking in terms of trail protection, is it fair to say they are pretty damned close, if you want a semi-auto go with a 10mm, if you want a revolver take the .357, but basically other than ...

A 9mm fires a .357 bullet ranging from 115 to 147 grains with up to 450 ft/lbs. of muzzle energy. The 10mm fires a .40 bullet weighing 180-230 grains with energies up to 700 ft/lbs. 10mm has noticeably more recoil. 9mm is good for protection while 10mm can be used for hunting. ... 9mm vs 10mm for bear defense.

A friend who worked near brown bears in Alaska years ago was issued a 375 H&H Magnum, and required to carry it everywhere. That is 4000 ft-lbs of energy. A 44 Magnum runs around 750-1000, depending on ammo and barrel, and the 357 is below that. Depends on where he goes and how much threat he expects.The heaviest and deepest penetrating 10mm in existence! This hardcast Wide Flat Nose Gas - Checked bullet will not deform on impact, and will create a large deep wound channel. Excellent for hunting or woods protection! Caliber : 10mm Bullet : 230gr Wide Flat Nose Gas Check Hardcast Ballistics : 1120fps/ 641 ft./lbs. - Glock 20Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...I carry the 357 once in a while but it is a lot of extra weight. Not fond it. Black bears in NH? I wouldn't worry about it. But if you want bear protection, shoot what you can shoot accurately. Tough to be the accuracy of bear spray, kind of like a shotgun. Black bears are not going to stalk you and the bulk of their diet are plants.Muzzle Energy - 414 ft. lbs. Underwood Ammo 357 Sig 147 Grain XTP Jacketed Hollow Point. Muzzle Velocity - 1250 fps. Muzzle Energy - 510 ft. lbs. Underwood Ammo 10mm 200 Grain XTP Jacketed Hollow Point. Muzzle Velocity - 1250 fps. Muzzle Energy - 694 ft. lbs. FNH 5.7x28mm 40 Grain Hornady V-Max. Muzzle Velocity - 2034 fps.10mm vs .357 Handguns: General Handgun Forum. The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: General Handgun Forum: 10mm vs .35722lr vs brown bear: ... .458 Socom, .450 Bushmaster, .357 Yeti, and even the crazy .358 WSSM all offer excellent performance on larger game within a few hundred yards. You just pay for it in reduced capacity and increased recoil. ... Is the velocity higher on an ar vs 10mm thus penetrating further. Is the big bore better causing more damage. ...The 45 ACP Glock 30 is much more comfortable and easy to shoot. The 45 ACP has that slow-rolling recoil, whereas the 10mm has that snap and fury. The 45 ACP allows for faster follow-up shots and at average self-defense ranges, follow up shots are important. The 45 ACP tends to be less flashy in shorter barrels as well.Ultimately, the quick answer is that 10mm Auto has higher muzzle velocity and, therefore, more recoil. On average, a 230-grain 45 ACP round has 7.5 ft-lbs (foot-pounds) of felt recoil, while a 180-grain 10mm load has 11.4 ft-lbs. That means the 10mm has over 50% more recoil than the 45 ACP, which is pretty substantial for many shooters.Velocity/Energy/Drop. When 10mm ammo has a 180 grain bullet and 1,250 fps muzzle velocity, its muzzle energy is 624 ft lbs. The 357 Magnum's heavyweight 158 grain bullet at the same muzzle velocity translates to a 14 percent loss of energy. Compared to the 9mm there is no contest — the 10mm's heavier, faster bullet necessarily does far ...Ultimately, the quick answer is that 10mm Auto has higher muzzle velocity and, therefore, more recoil. On average, a 230-grain 45 ACP round has 7.5 ft-lbs (foot-pounds) of felt recoil, while a 180-grain 10mm load has 11.4 ft-lbs. That means the 10mm has over 50% more recoil than the 45 ACP, which is pretty substantial for many shooters.

The .357 has better SD and better penetration and more energy. 10mm will cover most anything a .357 can do so they are pretty much interchangeable in the woods. On the street added firepower of 10mm would be an advantage. So go with your 10mm. For big dangerous stuff you would want .44, .45 .454, .460, .475, .500.The .357 magnum has a long track record of one-shot stops on attackers of all types. The 10mm is somewhat of a newcomer that might not have been around as long, but has become a major carry caliber for bear hunters or anyone else needing extra power. YouTuber mark3smle chooses to use ballistic gelatin to see what each caliber is capable of.The .41 Magnum falls between the .357 Magnum and the .44 Magnum in terms of power and recoil, making it a versatile option for bear defense. 3. What type of bullets should I use with a .41 Magnum for bear defense? Hard-cast lead bullets or heavy jacketed hollow points are recommended for bear defense with a .41 Magnum. 4.Instagram:https://instagram. hunting season indiana deeracxion pills reviewpublix midtown atlanta pharmacydocs sauble river inn menu The diameter of a .357 Magnum cartridge is 0.357 inches (9.0678 millimeters). The diameter of a 10mm Auto cartridge is 0.4 inches (10.16 millimeters). The .357 Magnum cartridge has a smaller diameter than the 10mm Auto cartridge by 0.043 inches. The overall length of a cartridge determines how deep a bullet will sit in a case. is kratom legal in costa ricamckinley funeral home in clintonville pa Here in Wyoming most locals prefer 41 magnum as a minimum revolver caliber. The 10mm pistol is getting more traction all the time. Hard cast bullets are the norm in all handguns for large bear. You can get more rounds off with a pistol. A glock in 10mm loaded with 200 gr hard cast would be my recommendation along with plenty of range time.But the 10mm is comparable to some of the 357 "bear loads" commercially available. Revelation 19:10 . . . worship God: for the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of ... We settle the debate over the best bear defense pistol cartridge— 10mm vs 44 Mag. —with this simple, but challenging shooting drill. www.outdoorlife.com Revelation 19:10 . . . ... highway 12 cameras Page 4- 10mm vs .357 Handguns: General Handgun Forum. The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: General Handgun Forum: 10mm vs .35710mm- Good woods option. Just know that most affordable 10mm will still be expensive, and all you'll really get is a 40sw. 357sig- Fun, precise, but financially impractical. There are 9mm and 40sw defense rounds that mirror 357sig ballistically.